SUSTAINABLE EUGENE?
Eugene Sustainability Quiz
Eugene Sustainability Commission
steps toward sincere sustainability
City Manager or democracy?
Regional Transportation Plan: $817 million for roads
2010-2015: Cities & County $186.5 million for roads
EWEB's $85 million new maintenance yard
U of O Arenas - Bus Rapid Transit - big box stores
hospitals - disasters - intelligent urban design - trains
grass seed to grains - food security, no more field burning

WEST EUGENE PORKWAY
WETLANDS: West Eugene Transportation, Land and Neighborhood Design Solutions - WEP alternative
Mayoral Election bypasses highway history
Kitty Piercy's West Eugene Collaborators excluded neighborhood groups, tolerates half a WEP
Jim Torrey wasted money promoting WEP after June 2001 "No Build" consensus by Fed, State, County & City
the 2001 City vote for the WEP - a federal, not local, decision
WEP violated laws signed by Nixon and LBJ
Lane County: Bobby Green vs. Rob Handy

related websites: forestclimate.org - oilempire.us - permatopia.com - road-scholar.org
feedback to mark at permatopia dot com

 

major changes proposed for WEP

 

1951 to 1972: Roosevelt Freeway proposal

1959 map

1967 map

 

1978: 6th / 7th Extension

Whiteaker Bypass

6th / 7th Freeway

 

1990 WEP Approved Design
approved in Final EIS and Record of Decision

WEP route: south of railroad tracks
west 11th connection: no direction connection
Danebo: at grade intersection, severe congestion at this location (no traffic light proposed)
Beltline interchange: no interchange, traffic light controlled intersection, Beltline stays two lanes wide
BLM impacts: proposed before BLM bought most of its parcels, but still would have major impact on these parklands
Seneca intersection: one extra turn lane in each direction (left, right) on each road in each direction of travel
6th / 7th terminus: at grade intersection, westbound traffic congestion would reach "failure" at traffic light

 

1997 WEP Modified Design
proposed in Supplemental Final EIS after ROD withdrawn in 1996 due to lawsuit

WEP route: part of route relocated north of railroad tracks (Amazon Creek to western terminus) to shift impacts to different parts of the wetlands
Danebo: at grade intersection removed (too close to Beltline interchange), grade separation without any connection (Hyundai traffic would have to use Beltline instead)
Beltline interchange: grade separated interchange approved in 1995 Beltline Environmental Assessment (supposedly separate project)
BLM impacts: greater than Approved Design, more acreage impacted between Danebo and Green Hill roads
Seneca intersection: double left turns on WEP, single left turns on Seneca - a very wide intersection that would be difficult for pedestrians (by ODOT's admission)
6th / 7th terminus: westbound flyover ramp added for 6th to WEP traffic (over 99 / 7th traffic)

 

2000 WEP System Cost
ODOT presentation to Eugene City Council

Modified Design plus:

 

2001 No Build Consensus
agreed to by Federal Highway Administration, BLM, ODOT, Lane County, City of Eugene and others
June 19, 2001 West Eugene Charette

Select "No Build" for WEP
Complete Beltline to West 11th
Preserve West 11th as an "expressway" from Commercial Street (east of Beltline) to Fisher Road (west of Green Hill)
Start process to examine West 11th design east of Beltline (the City owned section)

 

November, 2001 election - Measure 20-54 - WEP
Modified Project, no mention of Beltline interchange or other needed tributary projects
$88 million price tag ignored full "System Cost"

 

2001 election - Measure 20-53 - "not including WEP"
option crafted by City of Eugene staff as alleged alternative to the WEP

20-53 still included WEP from Seneca Road to Danebo despite repeated statements from FHWA and ODOT that this form of "segmentation" was illegal under federal law. Building two-thirds of WEP would be more illegal than building the whole thing.

 

2002 TransPlan amendments for WEP

The TransPlan amendments enacted in July 2002 included the WEP Modified Design and removed Beltline Phase 3 (Roosevelt to West 11th) and the West 11th widening (Terry to Green Hill) from the transportation budget. Terry Street Extended was not included for addition or removal - some officials claim it was part of WEP, but the 1997 SDEIS stated it was a separate project.

 

2002 Crandall Arambula WEP route
proposed by a Portland architecture firm also working to greenwash the Peace Health relocation effort

would build WEP from Seneca to Danebo (supposedly only for express buses)
new route for WEP west of Danebo to Green Hill with greater acreage of wetland destruction than WEP
Roosevelt Blvd. extension from Terry Street to new WEP route (specifically prohibited in 2000 West Eugene Wetlands plan)
Bus only expressway parallel to Green Hill Road from Royal Avenue to Eugene Airport
new WEP (cars and buses) from Royal / Green Hill intersection across Oak Hill to Highway 126 at proposed WEP western terminus
This proposal was unveiled to the public at a press conference sponsored by a couple of confused environmentalists who ignored warnings from numerous allies that this "alternative" would be worse than ODOT's proposal. It would have gone through the Royal Blue Organic blueberry farm, more BLM land than WEP, and near or through homes that are not directly threatened by WEP. Despite numerous requests, the sponsors of this strange scenario never explained why they recommended this - even ODOT was surprised by this. Due to overwhelming negative reaction, the proposal was quietly dropped and some of the sponsors have quietly admitted it was a mistake. WEP supporters continue to reference this proposal to claim that even the opponents want a new expressway -- and the Crandall Arambula promoters have declined numerous opportunities to point out that they do not want this.

 

2003 to 2004 WEP Alternative A Modified
unveiled in 2004 EIS "Re-evaluation" report - $169 million

WEP Modified Alternative plus Beltline Phase 3

Seneca intersection modified to prohibit left turns from WEP to Seneca (Seneca to WEP left turns still allowed), ODOT was unable to design a route that would solve congestion problem created at that intersection,

ODOT turns over maintenance responsibility for WEP east of Beltline to the City due to the inability to meet ODOT's stricter congestion mitigation standards

The "re-evaluation" admitted that Roosevelt at Highway 99 would still be at "failure" in the design year of 2025 whether WEP is built or not -- a reason to shift some of the WEP's construction money toward fixing that dangerous intersection as part of the alternative to the WEP.

One option studied during this time frame was a completely grade separated road (interchanges instead of intersections at all crossings), which would have been at least $200 million.

 

May, 2005 unnamed modification of WEP Alternative A modified
unveiled at public presentation at Willamette High School (and nowhere else, it seems)

Alternative A Modified plus a second flyover ramp for eastbound WEP traffic at 7th Avenue terminus
no cost estimate is available

 

October, 2005 WEP Couplet Alternative
unveiled at October 2005 River Road Neighborhood Association meeting by ODOT officials

Alternative A Modified west of Seneca
no expressway east of Seneca
no Terry Street extension
no grade separation of Roosevelt from Beltline
no widening of West 11th from Terry to Green Hill
at grade intersections at 6th and 7th Streets
(rejected in 1997 and 2005, respectively)
continue WEP traffic onto 5th (eastbound) and 7th (westbound) between Seneca and 99 (rejected in 1985 as unpopular and impractical)
no cost figures available, but it would be cheaper due to the lack of flyover ramps at the eastern terminus and associated business disruptions. However, this is also a form of "segmentation" prohibited by federal law, so the full cost of the eastern terminus will still be required to be included before the Final EIS can be approved.

 

WEP version on the ballot in November 2001

 

WEP "Alternative A Mitigated" - summer 2003

 

 

WEP 2005 Couplet Alternative -- unveiled October 2005